[Met_help] [rt.rap.ucar.edu #44207] History for problem in grid_stat output

RAL HelpDesk {for Paul Oldenburg} met_help at ucar.edu
Wed Feb 9 12:22:31 MST 2011


----------------------------------------------------------------
  Initial Request
----------------------------------------------------------------

VERSION MODEL FCST_LEAD FCST_VALID_BEG  FCST_VALID_END  OBS_LEAD OBS_VALID_BEG   OBS_VALID_END   FCST_VAR FCST_LEV OBS_VAR OBS_LEV OBTYPE VX_MASK INTERP_MTHD INTERP_PNTS FCST_THRESH OBS_THRESH COV_THRESH ALPHA   LINE_TYPE TOTAL  FBAR         FBAR_NCL     FBAR_NCU     FBAR_BCL FBAR_BCU FSTDEV    FSTDEV_NCL FSTDEV_NCU FSTDEV_BCL FSTDEV_BCU OBAR         OBAR_NCL     OBAR_NCU     OBAR_BCL OBAR_BCU OSTDEV     OSTDEV_NCL OSTDEV_NCU OSTDEV_BCL OSTDEV_BCU PR_CORR PR_CORR_NCL PR_CORR_NCU PR_CORR_BCL PR_CORR_BCU SP_CORR KT_CORR RANKS FRANK_TIES ORANK_TIES ME        ME_NCL    ME_NCU    ME_BCL ME_BCU ESTDEV    ESTDEV_NCL ESTDEV_NCU ESTDEV_BCL ESTDEV_BCU MBIAS      MBIAS_BCL MBIAS_BCU MAE       MAE_BCL MAE_BCU MSE         MSE_BCL MSE_BCU BCMSE       BCMSE_BCL BCMSE_BCU RMSE      RMSE_BCL RMSE_BCU E10        E10_BCL E10_BCU E25       E25_BCL E25_BCU E50       E50_BCL E50_BCU E75      E75_BCL E75_BCU E90       E90_BCL E90_BCU
V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000   20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P200     UGRD    P200    ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA         0.05000 CNT       104229 12.72428     12.56397     12.88458     NA       NA       26.40506  26.29220   26.51890   NA         NA         13.31753     13.15803     13.47703     NA       NA       26.27261   26.16031   26.38588   NA         NA         0.97917 0.97892     0.97942     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          -0.59326  -0.62590  -0.56061  NA     NA     5.37733   5.35434    5.40051    NA         NA         0.95545    NA        NA        4.14550   NA      NA      29.26732    NA      NA      28.91537    NA        NA        5.40993   NA       NA       -7.53975   NA      NA      -3.73896  NA      NA      -0.01006  NA      NA      2.91055  NA      NA      5.69081   NA      NA
V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000   20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P850     UGRD    P850    ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA         0.05000 CNT       104229 -0.92424     -0.96596     -0.88252     NA       NA       6.87219   6.84281    6.90182    NA         NA         -0.09031     -0.12305     -0.05758     NA       NA       5.39198    5.36893    5.41523    NA         NA         0.86552 0.86399     0.86703     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          -0.83392  -0.85509  -0.81276  NA     NA     3.48676   3.47186    3.50179    NA         NA         10.23372   NA        NA        2.70852   NA      NA      12.85280    NA      NA      12.15737    NA        NA        3.58508   NA       NA       -5.33030   NA      NA      -2.80985  NA      NA      -0.57019  NA      NA      1.34960  NA      NA      3.32039   NA      NA
V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000   20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P200     VGRD    P200    ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA         0.05000 CNT       104229 1.20188      1.13867      1.26508      NA       NA       10.41115  10.36665   10.45604   NA         NA         0.00086      -0.06367     0.06540      NA       NA       10.63064   10.58520   10.67648   NA         NA         0.87388 0.87244     0.87531     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          1.20102   1.16891   1.23312   NA     NA     5.28821   5.26561    5.31101    NA         NA         1392.29592 NA        NA        3.77652   NA      NA      29.40732    NA      NA      27.96488    NA        NA        5.42285   NA       NA       -4.40088   NA      NA      -1.85968  NA      NA      0.57003   NA      NA      3.58032  NA      NA      7.38005   NA      NA
V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000   20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P850     VGRD    P850    ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA         0.05000 CNT       104229 -0.57983     -0.60585     -0.55380     NA       NA       4.28728   4.26896    4.30577    NA         NA         -0.22396     -0.24579     -0.20212     NA       NA       3.59671    3.58134    3.61222    NA         NA         0.79578 0.79354     0.79800     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          -0.35587  -0.37167  -0.34007  NA     NA     2.60289   2.59176    2.61411    NA         NA         2.58899    NA        NA        2.06063   NA      NA      6.90160     NA      NA      6.77495     NA        NA        2.62709   NA       NA       -3.62999   NA      NA      -2.03975  NA      NA      -0.30993  NA      NA      1.36034  NA      NA      2.86965   NA      NA
V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000   20110104_000000 20110104_000000 HGT      P500     HGT     P500    ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA         0.05000 CNT       104229 5757.47921   5756.67392   5758.28450   NA       NA       132.64678 132.07980  133.21867  NA         NA         5760.36436   5759.58847   5761.14026   NA       NA       127.80583  127.25955  128.35686  NA         NA         0.99764 0.99761     0.99766     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          -2.88515  -2.94694  -2.82337  NA     NA     10.17761  10.13411   10.22149   NA         NA         0.99950    NA        NA        7.19162   NA      NA      111.90687   NA      NA      103.58276   NA        NA        10.57860  NA       NA       -13.39664  NA      NA      -6.75918  NA      NA      -2.09283  NA      NA      2.76461  NA      NA      7.51232   NA      NA
V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000   20110104_000000 20110104_000000 RH       P700     RH      P700    ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA         0.05000 CNT       104229 50.53367     50.36545     50.70189     NA       NA       27.70964  27.59120   27.82911   NA         NA         51.14431     50.97575     51.31287     NA       NA       27.76553   27.64685   27.88524   NA         NA         0.82485 0.82290     0.82678     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          -0.61064  -0.71031  -0.51098  NA     NA     16.41677  16.34660   16.48755   NA         NA         0.98806    NA        NA        12.08873  NA      NA      269.88072   NA      NA      269.50784   NA        NA        16.42805  NA       NA       -20.31021  NA      NA      -9.32042  NA      NA      -0.75999  NA      NA      8.28050  NA      NA      19.76888  NA      NA
V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000   20110104_000000 20110104_000000 DPT      L002     DPT     L002    ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA         0.05000 CNT       104229 282.71981    282.62088    282.81874    NA       NA       16.29619  16.22653   16.36645   NA         NA         281.86912    281.76724    281.97100    NA       NA       16.78184   16.71011   16.85419   NA         NA         0.98777 0.98762     0.98791     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          0.85069   0.83471   0.86667   NA     NA     2.63195   2.62070    2.64330    NA         NA         1.00302    NA        NA        1.87497   NA      NA      7.65076     NA      NA      6.92709     NA        NA        2.76600   NA       NA       -1.61755   NA      NA      -0.14540  NA      NA      0.82517   NA      NA      1.76625  NA      NA      3.58419   NA      NA
V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000   20110104_000000 20110104_000000 TMP      L002     TMP     L002    ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA         0.05000 CNT       104229 288.08059    287.99342    288.16776    NA       NA       14.35860  14.29722   14.42050   NA         NA         287.65343    287.55967    287.74719    NA       NA       15.44427   15.37825   15.51085   NA         NA         0.99355 0.99347     0.99362     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          0.42716   0.41496   0.43937   NA     NA     2.01018   2.00158    2.01884    NA         NA         1.00148    NA        NA        1.37606   NA      NA      4.22324     NA      NA      4.04077     NA        NA        2.05505   NA       NA       -1.33962   NA      NA      -0.72940  NA      NA      -0.10933  NA      NA      1.16036  NA      NA      3.27992   NA      NA
V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000   20110104_000000 20110104_000000 PRMSL    L000     PRMSL   L000    ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA         0.05000 CNT       104229 101506.27461 101500.32308 101512.22613 NA       NA       980.33535 976.14508  984.56200  NA         NA         101552.32536 101545.96644 101558.68428 NA       NA       1047.44127 1042.96417 1051.95724 NA         NA         0.97981 0.97956     0.98005     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          -46.05075 -47.35240 -44.74911 NA     NA     214.40667 213.49022  215.33107  NA         NA         0.99955    NA        NA        129.08656 NA      NA      48090.44934 NA      NA      45969.77759 NA        NA        219.29535 NA       NA       -217.44225 NA      NA      -98.55026 NA      NA      -24.52207 NA      NA      42.98074 NA      NA      125.68678 NA      NA


----------------------------------------------------------------
  Complete Ticket History
----------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: Re: [rt.rap.ucar.edu #44207] problem in grid_stat output
From: Paul Oldenburg
Time: Wed Feb 09 08:45:26 2011

Hashmi,

I was able to download your config file, test script, output files and
input GRIB files, but there are no observation
files.  I see an empty folder on the FTP site called 2010070100.  Did
you intend for that to contain observation data?
If so, please upload it and I will look at your problem.

Thanks,

Paul


On 02/09/2011 06:38 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
>
> Wed Feb 09 06:38:46 2011: Request 44207 was acted upon.
> Transaction: Ticket created by hashmifatima at gmail.com
>        Queue: met_help
>      Subject: problem in grid_stat output
>        Owner: Nobody
>   Requestors: hashmifatima at gmail.com
>       Status: new
>  Ticket <URL:
https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207 >
>
>
> VERSION MODEL FCST_LEAD FCST_VALID_BEG  FCST_VALID_END  OBS_LEAD
OBS_VALID_BEG   OBS_VALID_END   FCST_VAR FCST_LEV OBS_VAR OBS_LEV
OBTYPE VX_MASK INTERP_MTHD INTERP_PNTS FCST_THRESH OBS_THRESH
COV_THRESH ALPHA   LINE_TYPE TOTAL  FBAR         FBAR_NCL     FBAR_NCU
FBAR_BCL FBAR_BCU FSTDEV    FSTDEV_NCL FSTDEV_NCU FSTDEV_BCL
FSTDEV_BCU OBAR         OBAR_NCL     OBAR_NCU     OBAR_BCL OBAR_BCU
OSTDEV     OSTDEV_NCL OSTDEV_NCU OSTDEV_BCL OSTDEV_BCU PR_CORR
PR_CORR_NCL PR_CORR_NCU PR_CORR_BCL PR_CORR_BCU SP_CORR KT_CORR RANKS
FRANK_TIES ORANK_TIES ME        ME_NCL    ME_NCU    ME_BCL ME_BCU
ESTDEV    ESTDEV_NCL ESTDEV_NCU ESTDEV_BCL ESTDEV_BCU MBIAS
MBIAS_BCL MBIAS_BCU MAE       MAE_BCL MAE_BCU MSE         MSE_BCL
MSE_BCU BCMSE       BCMSE_BCL BCMSE_BCU RMSE      RMSE_BCL RMSE_BCU
E10        E10_BCL E10_BCU E25       E25_BCL E25_BCU E50       E50_BCL
E50_BCU E75      E75_BCL E75_BCU E90       E90_BCL E90_BCU
> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P200     UGRD    P200
ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000 CNT       104229 12.72428     12.56397     12.88458     NA
NA       26.40506  26.29220   26.51890   NA         NA
13.31753     13.15803     13.47703     NA       NA       26.27261
26.16031   26.38588   NA         NA         0.97917 0.97892
0.97942     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0
-0.59326  -0.62590  -0.56061  NA     NA     5.37733   5.35434
5.40051    NA         NA         0.95545    NA        NA
4.14550   NA      NA      29.26732    NA      NA      28.91537    NA
NA        5.40993   NA       NA       -7.53975   NA      NA
-3.73896  NA      NA      -0.01006  NA      NA      2.91055  NA
NA      5.69081   NA      NA
> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P850     UGRD    P850
ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000 CNT       104229 -0.92424     -0.96596     -0.88252     NA
NA       6.87219   6.84281    6.90182    NA         NA
-0.09031     -0.12305     -0.05758     NA       NA       5.39198
5.36893    5.41523    NA         NA         0.86552 0.86399
0.86703     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0
-0.83392  -0.85509  -0.81276  NA     NA     3.48676   3.47186
3.50179    NA         NA         10.23372   NA        NA
2.70852   NA      NA      12.85280    NA      NA      12.15737    NA
NA        3.58508   NA       NA       -5.33030   NA      NA
-2.80985  NA      NA      -0.57019  NA      NA      1.34960  NA
NA      3.32039   NA      NA
> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P200     VGRD    P200
ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000 CNT       104229 1.20188      1.13867      1.26508      NA
NA       10.41115  10.36665   10.45604   NA         NA         0.00086
-0.06367     0.06540      NA       NA       10.63064   10.58520
10.67648   NA         NA         0.87388 0.87244     0.87531     NA
NA          NA      NA      0     0          0          1.20102
1.16891   1.23312   NA     NA     5.28821   5.26561    5.31101    NA
NA         1392.29592 NA        NA        3.77652   NA      NA
29.40732    NA      NA      27.96488    NA        NA        5.42285
NA       NA       -4.40088   NA      NA      -1.85968  NA      NA
0.57003   NA      NA      3.58032  NA      NA      7.38005   NA
NA
> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P850     VGRD    P850
ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000 CNT       104229 -0.57983     -0.60585     -0.55380     NA
NA       4.28728   4.26896    4.30577    NA         NA
-0.22396     -0.24579     -0.20212     NA       NA       3.59671
3.58134    3.61222    NA         NA         0.79578 0.79354
0.79800     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0
-0.35587  -0.37167  -0.34007  NA     NA     2.60289   2.59176
2.61411    NA         NA         2.58899    NA        NA
2.06063   NA      NA      6.90160     NA      NA      6.77495     NA
NA        2.62709   NA       NA       -3.62999   NA      NA
-2.03975  NA      NA      -0.30993  NA      NA      1.36034  NA
NA      2.86965   NA      NA
> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
20110104_000000 20110104_000000 HGT      P500     HGT     P500
ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000 CNT       104229 5757.47921   5756.67392   5758.28450   NA
NA       132.64678 132.07980  133.21867  NA         NA
5760.36436   5759.58847   5761.14026   NA       NA       127.80583
127.25955  128.35686  NA         NA         0.99764 0.99761
0.99766     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0
-2.88515  -2.94694  -2.82337  NA     NA     10.17761  10.13411
10.22149   NA         NA         0.99950    NA        NA
7.19162   NA      NA      111.90687   NA      NA      103.58276   NA
NA        10.57860  NA       NA       -13.39664  NA      NA
-6.75918  NA      NA      -2.09283  NA      NA      2.76461  NA
NA      7.51232   NA      NA
> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
20110104_000000 20110104_000000 RH       P700     RH      P700
ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000 CNT       104229 50.53367     50.36545     50.70189     NA
NA       27.70964  27.59120   27.82911   NA         NA
51.14431     50.97575     51.31287     NA       NA       27.76553
27.64685   27.88524   NA         NA         0.82485 0.82290
0.82678     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0
-0.61064  -0.71031  -0.51098  NA     NA     16.41677  16.34660
16.48755   NA         NA         0.98806    NA        NA
12.08873  NA      NA      269.88072   NA      NA      269.50784   NA
NA        16.42805  NA       NA       -20.31021  NA      NA
-9.32042  NA      NA      -0.75999  NA      NA      8.28050  NA
NA      19.76888  NA      NA
> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
20110104_000000 20110104_000000 DPT      L002     DPT     L002
ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000 CNT       104229 282.71981    282.62088    282.81874    NA
NA       16.29619  16.22653   16.36645   NA         NA
281.86912    281.76724    281.97100    NA       NA       16.78184
16.71011   16.85419   NA         NA         0.98777 0.98762
0.98791     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0
0.85069   0.83471   0.86667   NA     NA     2.63195   2.62070
2.64330    NA         NA         1.00302    NA        NA
1.87497   NA      NA      7.65076     NA      NA      6.92709     NA
NA        2.76600   NA       NA       -1.61755   NA      NA
-0.14540  NA      NA      0.82517   NA      NA      1.76625  NA
NA      3.58419   NA      NA
> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
20110104_000000 20110104_000000 TMP      L002     TMP     L002
ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000 CNT       104229 288.08059    287.99342    288.16776    NA
NA       14.35860  14.29722   14.42050   NA         NA
287.65343    287.55967    287.74719    NA       NA       15.44427
15.37825   15.51085   NA         NA         0.99355 0.99347
0.99362     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0
0.42716   0.41496   0.43937   NA     NA     2.01018   2.00158
2.01884    NA         NA         1.00148    NA        NA
1.37606   NA      NA      4.22324     NA      NA      4.04077     NA
NA        2.05505   NA       NA       -1.33962   NA      NA
-0.72940  NA      NA      -0.10933  NA      NA      1.16036  NA
NA      3.27992   NA      NA
> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
20110104_000000 20110104_000000 PRMSL    L000     PRMSL   L000
ANALYS FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000 CNT       104229 101506.27461 101500.32308 101512.22613 NA
NA       980.33535 976.14508  984.56200  NA         NA
101552.32536 101545.96644 101558.68428 NA       NA       1047.44127
1042.96417 1051.95724 NA         NA         0.97981 0.97956
0.98005     NA          NA          NA      NA      0     0          0
-46.05075 -47.35240 -44.74911 NA     NA     214.40667 213.49022
215.33107  NA         NA         0.99955    NA        NA
129.08656 NA      NA      48090.44934 NA      NA      45969.77759 NA
NA        219.29535 NA       NA       -217.44225 NA      NA
-98.55026 NA      NA      -24.52207 NA      NA      42.98074 NA
NA      125.68678 NA      NA
>
>
>
> Dear Sir,
>
> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all other
variable
> in the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
>
> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have uploaded
input
> files at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
> Please check my script, input file and output files.
>
>
> Thanks and Regards,
>
>
>
> Dear Sir,
>
> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all other
variable in
> the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
>
> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have uploaded
input files
> at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
> Please check my script, input file and output files.
>
>
> Thanks and Regards,
> --
> Hashmi Fatima
> Research Scholar
> Centre for Atmospheric Sciences
> Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
> Hauz Khas
> New Delhi - 110016
> INDIA


------------------------------------------------
Subject: problem in grid_stat output
From: Hashmi Fatima
Time: Wed Feb 09 08:52:56 2011

No that was some old folder. I was trying to upload wrf_t00z_000.grib1
and
wrf_t00z.024.grib1 files. It was taking much time. so i left them to
upload.

I checked these files they were OK. I will try to send them tomorrow.

Regards,
Hashmi Fatima

On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 9:15 PM, RAL HelpDesk {for Paul Oldenburg} <
met_help at ucar.edu> wrote:

> Hashmi,
>
> I was able to download your config file, test script, output files
and
> input GRIB files, but there are no observation
> files.  I see an empty folder on the FTP site called 2010070100.
Did you
> intend for that to contain observation data?
> If so, please upload it and I will look at your problem.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Paul
>
>
> On 02/09/2011 06:38 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
> >
> > Wed Feb 09 06:38:46 2011: Request 44207 was acted upon.
> > Transaction: Ticket created by hashmifatima at gmail.com
> >        Queue: met_help
> >      Subject: problem in grid_stat output
> >        Owner: Nobody
> >   Requestors: hashmifatima at gmail.com
> >       Status: new
> >  Ticket <URL:
https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207 >
> >
> >
> > VERSION MODEL FCST_LEAD FCST_VALID_BEG  FCST_VALID_END  OBS_LEAD
> OBS_VALID_BEG   OBS_VALID_END   FCST_VAR FCST_LEV OBS_VAR OBS_LEV
OBTYPE
> VX_MASK INTERP_MTHD INTERP_PNTS FCST_THRESH OBS_THRESH COV_THRESH
ALPHA
> LINE_TYPE TOTAL  FBAR         FBAR_NCL     FBAR_NCU     FBAR_BCL
FBAR_BCU
> FSTDEV    FSTDEV_NCL FSTDEV_NCU FSTDEV_BCL FSTDEV_BCU OBAR
OBAR_NCL
>     OBAR_NCU     OBAR_BCL OBAR_BCU OSTDEV     OSTDEV_NCL OSTDEV_NCU
> OSTDEV_BCL OSTDEV_BCU PR_CORR PR_CORR_NCL PR_CORR_NCU PR_CORR_BCL
> PR_CORR_BCU SP_CORR KT_CORR RANKS FRANK_TIES ORANK_TIES ME
ME_NCL
>  ME_NCU    ME_BCL ME_BCU ESTDEV    ESTDEV_NCL ESTDEV_NCU ESTDEV_BCL
> ESTDEV_BCU MBIAS      MBIAS_BCL MBIAS_BCU MAE       MAE_BCL MAE_BCU
MSE
>     MSE_BCL MSE_BCU BCMSE       BCMSE_BCL BCMSE_BCU RMSE
RMSE_BCL
> RMSE_BCU E10        E10_BCL E10_BCU E25       E25_BCL E25_BCU E50
> E50_BCL E50_BCU E75      E75_BCL E75_BCU E90       E90_BCL E90_BCU
> > V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P200     UGRD    P200
ANALYS
> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
> CNT       104229 12.72428     12.56397     12.88458     NA       NA
> 26.40506  26.29220   26.51890   NA         NA         13.31753
13.15803
>     13.47703     NA       NA       26.27261   26.16031   26.38588
NA
>   NA         0.97917 0.97892     0.97942     NA          NA
NA
>  NA      0     0          0          -0.59326  -0.62590  -0.56061
NA     NA
>     5.37733   5.35434    5.40051    NA         NA         0.95545
NA
>    NA        4.14550   NA      NA      29.26732    NA      NA
28.91537
>    NA        NA        5.40993   NA       NA       -7.53975   NA
NA
>  -3.73896  NA      NA      -0.01006  NA      NA      2.91055  NA
NA
>  5.69081   NA      NA
> > V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P850     UGRD    P850
ANALYS
> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
> CNT       104229 -0.92424     -0.96596     -0.88252     NA       NA
> 6.87219   6.84281    6.90182    NA         NA         -0.09031
-0.12305
>     -0.05758     NA       NA       5.39198    5.36893    5.41523
NA
>   NA         0.86552 0.86399     0.86703     NA          NA
NA
>  NA      0     0          0          -0.83392  -0.85509  -0.81276
NA     NA
>     3.48676   3.47186    3.50179    NA         NA         10.23372
NA
>    NA        2.70852   NA      NA      12.85280    NA      NA
12.15737
>    NA        NA        3.58508   NA       NA       -5.33030   NA
NA
>  -2.80985  NA      NA      -0.57019  NA      NA      1.34960  NA
NA
>  3.32039   NA      NA
> > V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P200     VGRD    P200
ANALYS
> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
> CNT       104229 1.20188      1.13867      1.26508      NA       NA
> 10.41115  10.36665   10.45604   NA         NA         0.00086
-0.06367
>     0.06540      NA       NA       10.63064   10.58520   10.67648
NA
>   NA         0.87388 0.87244     0.87531     NA          NA
NA
>  NA      0     0          0          1.20102   1.16891   1.23312
NA     NA
>     5.28821   5.26561    5.31101    NA         NA         1392.29592
NA
>    NA        3.77652   NA      NA      29.40732    NA      NA
27.96488
>    NA        NA        5.42285   NA       NA       -4.40088   NA
NA
>  -1.85968  NA      NA      0.57003   NA      NA      3.58032  NA
NA
>  7.38005   NA      NA
> > V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P850     VGRD    P850
ANALYS
> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
> CNT       104229 -0.57983     -0.60585     -0.55380     NA       NA
> 4.28728   4.26896    4.30577    NA         NA         -0.22396
-0.24579
>     -0.20212     NA       NA       3.59671    3.58134    3.61222
NA
>   NA         0.79578 0.79354     0.79800     NA          NA
NA
>  NA      0     0          0          -0.35587  -0.37167  -0.34007
NA     NA
>     2.60289   2.59176    2.61411    NA         NA         2.58899
NA
>    NA        2.06063   NA      NA      6.90160     NA      NA
6.77495
>   NA        NA        2.62709   NA       NA       -3.62999   NA
NA
>  -2.03975  NA      NA      -0.30993  NA      NA      1.36034  NA
NA
>  2.86965   NA      NA
> > V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 HGT      P500     HGT     P500
ANALYS
> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
> CNT       104229 5757.47921   5756.67392   5758.28450   NA       NA
> 132.64678 132.07980  133.21867  NA         NA         5760.36436
> 5759.58847   5761.14026   NA       NA       127.80583  127.25955
128.35686
>  NA         NA         0.99764 0.99761     0.99766     NA
NA
>    NA      NA      0     0          0          -2.88515  -2.94694
-2.82337
>  NA     NA     10.17761  10.13411   10.22149   NA         NA
0.99950
>    NA        NA        7.19162   NA      NA      111.90687   NA
NA
>  103.58276   NA        NA        10.57860  NA       NA
-13.39664  NA
>    NA      -6.75918  NA      NA      -2.09283  NA      NA
2.76461  NA
>    NA      7.51232   NA      NA
> > V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 RH       P700     RH      P700
ANALYS
> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
> CNT       104229 50.53367     50.36545     50.70189     NA       NA
> 27.70964  27.59120   27.82911   NA         NA         51.14431
50.97575
>     51.31287     NA       NA       27.76553   27.64685   27.88524
NA
>   NA         0.82485 0.82290     0.82678     NA          NA
NA
>  NA      0     0          0          -0.61064  -0.71031  -0.51098
NA     NA
>     16.41677  16.34660   16.48755   NA         NA         0.98806
NA
>    NA        12.08873  NA      NA      269.88072   NA      NA
269.50784
>   NA        NA        16.42805  NA       NA       -20.31021  NA
NA
>  -9.32042  NA      NA      -0.75999  NA      NA      8.28050  NA
NA
>  19.76888  NA      NA
> > V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 DPT      L002     DPT     L002
ANALYS
> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
> CNT       104229 282.71981    282.62088    282.81874    NA       NA
> 16.29619  16.22653   16.36645   NA         NA         281.86912
281.76724
>    281.97100    NA       NA       16.78184   16.71011   16.85419
NA
>   NA         0.98777 0.98762     0.98791     NA          NA
NA
>  NA      0     0          0          0.85069   0.83471   0.86667
NA     NA
>     2.63195   2.62070    2.64330    NA         NA         1.00302
NA
>    NA        1.87497   NA      NA      7.65076     NA      NA
6.92709
>   NA        NA        2.76600   NA       NA       -1.61755   NA
NA
>  -0.14540  NA      NA      0.82517   NA      NA      1.76625  NA
NA
>  3.58419   NA      NA
> > V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 TMP      L002     TMP     L002
ANALYS
> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
> CNT       104229 288.08059    287.99342    288.16776    NA       NA
> 14.35860  14.29722   14.42050   NA         NA         287.65343
287.55967
>    287.74719    NA       NA       15.44427   15.37825   15.51085
NA
>   NA         0.99355 0.99347     0.99362     NA          NA
NA
>  NA      0     0          0          0.42716   0.41496   0.43937
NA     NA
>     2.01018   2.00158    2.01884    NA         NA         1.00148
NA
>    NA        1.37606   NA      NA      4.22324     NA      NA
4.04077
>   NA        NA        2.05505   NA       NA       -1.33962   NA
NA
>  -0.72940  NA      NA      -0.10933  NA      NA      1.16036  NA
NA
>  3.27992   NA      NA
> > V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 PRMSL    L000     PRMSL   L000
ANALYS
> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
> CNT       104229 101506.27461 101500.32308 101512.22613 NA       NA
> 980.33535 976.14508  984.56200  NA         NA         101552.32536
> 101545.96644 101558.68428 NA       NA       1047.44127 1042.96417
1051.95724
> NA         NA         0.97981 0.97956     0.98005     NA          NA
>  NA      NA      0     0          0          -46.05075 -47.35240
-44.74911
> NA     NA     214.40667 213.49022  215.33107  NA         NA
0.99955
>    NA        NA        129.08656 NA      NA      48090.44934 NA
NA
>  45969.77759 NA        NA        219.29535 NA       NA
-217.44225 NA
>    NA      -98.55026 NA      NA      -24.52207 NA      NA
42.98074 NA
>    NA      125.68678 NA      NA
> >
> >
> >
> > Dear Sir,
> >
> > I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
> > The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
> variable
> > in the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
> >
> > I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have uploaded
input
> > files at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
> > Please check my script, input file and output files.
> >
> >
> > Thanks and Regards,
> >
> >
> >
> > Dear Sir,
> >
> > I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
> > The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
> variable in
> > the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
> >
> > I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have uploaded
input
> files
> > at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
> > Please check my script, input file and output files.
> >
> >
> > Thanks and Regards,
> > --
> > Hashmi Fatima
> > Research Scholar
> > Centre for Atmospheric Sciences
> > Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
> > Hauz Khas
> > New Delhi - 110016
> > INDIA
>
>
>


--
Hashmi Fatima
Research Scholar
Centre for Atmospheric Sciences
Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
Hauz Khas
New Delhi - 110016
INDIA

------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: [rt.rap.ucar.edu #44207] problem in grid_stat output
From: Paul Oldenburg
Time: Wed Feb 09 09:03:26 2011

Hashmi,

I assumed the files WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.000.grib1 and
WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.024.grib1 were both model output files that you wanted
to verify.  Is one of those file the observation data and one the
model data?

Paul

On 02/09/2011 08:52 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
>
> <URL: https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207 >
>
> No that was some old folder. I was trying to upload
wrf_t00z_000.grib1 and
> wrf_t00z.024.grib1 files. It was taking much time. so i left them to
> upload.
>
> I checked these files they were OK. I will try to send them
tomorrow.
>
> Regards,
> Hashmi Fatima
>
> On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 9:15 PM, RAL HelpDesk {for Paul Oldenburg} <
> met_help at ucar.edu> wrote:
>
>> Hashmi,
>>
>> I was able to download your config file, test script, output files
and
>> input GRIB files, but there are no observation
>> files.  I see an empty folder on the FTP site called 2010070100.
Did you
>> intend for that to contain observation data?
>> If so, please upload it and I will look at your problem.
>>
>> Thanks,
>>
>> Paul
>>
>>
>> On 02/09/2011 06:38 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
>>>
>>> Wed Feb 09 06:38:46 2011: Request 44207 was acted upon.
>>> Transaction: Ticket created by hashmifatima at gmail.com
>>>        Queue: met_help
>>>      Subject: problem in grid_stat output
>>>        Owner: Nobody
>>>   Requestors: hashmifatima at gmail.com
>>>       Status: new
>>>  Ticket <URL:
https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207 >
>>>
>>>
>>> VERSION MODEL FCST_LEAD FCST_VALID_BEG  FCST_VALID_END  OBS_LEAD
>> OBS_VALID_BEG   OBS_VALID_END   FCST_VAR FCST_LEV OBS_VAR OBS_LEV
OBTYPE
>> VX_MASK INTERP_MTHD INTERP_PNTS FCST_THRESH OBS_THRESH COV_THRESH
ALPHA
>> LINE_TYPE TOTAL  FBAR         FBAR_NCL     FBAR_NCU     FBAR_BCL
FBAR_BCU
>> FSTDEV    FSTDEV_NCL FSTDEV_NCU FSTDEV_BCL FSTDEV_BCU OBAR
OBAR_NCL
>>     OBAR_NCU     OBAR_BCL OBAR_BCU OSTDEV     OSTDEV_NCL OSTDEV_NCU
>> OSTDEV_BCL OSTDEV_BCU PR_CORR PR_CORR_NCL PR_CORR_NCU PR_CORR_BCL
>> PR_CORR_BCU SP_CORR KT_CORR RANKS FRANK_TIES ORANK_TIES ME
ME_NCL
>>  ME_NCU    ME_BCL ME_BCU ESTDEV    ESTDEV_NCL ESTDEV_NCU ESTDEV_BCL
>> ESTDEV_BCU MBIAS      MBIAS_BCL MBIAS_BCU MAE       MAE_BCL MAE_BCU
MSE
>>     MSE_BCL MSE_BCU BCMSE       BCMSE_BCL BCMSE_BCU RMSE
RMSE_BCL
>> RMSE_BCU E10        E10_BCL E10_BCU E25       E25_BCL E25_BCU E50
>> E50_BCL E50_BCU E75      E75_BCL E75_BCU E90       E90_BCL E90_BCU
>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P200     UGRD    P200
ANALYS
>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
>> CNT       104229 12.72428     12.56397     12.88458     NA       NA
>> 26.40506  26.29220   26.51890   NA         NA         13.31753
13.15803
>>     13.47703     NA       NA       26.27261   26.16031   26.38588
NA
>>   NA         0.97917 0.97892     0.97942     NA          NA
NA
>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.59326  -0.62590  -0.56061
NA     NA
>>     5.37733   5.35434    5.40051    NA         NA         0.95545
NA
>>    NA        4.14550   NA      NA      29.26732    NA      NA
28.91537
>>    NA        NA        5.40993   NA       NA       -7.53975   NA
NA
>>  -3.73896  NA      NA      -0.01006  NA      NA      2.91055  NA
NA
>>  5.69081   NA      NA
>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P850     UGRD    P850
ANALYS
>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
>> CNT       104229 -0.92424     -0.96596     -0.88252     NA       NA
>> 6.87219   6.84281    6.90182    NA         NA         -0.09031
-0.12305
>>     -0.05758     NA       NA       5.39198    5.36893    5.41523
NA
>>   NA         0.86552 0.86399     0.86703     NA          NA
NA
>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.83392  -0.85509  -0.81276
NA     NA
>>     3.48676   3.47186    3.50179    NA         NA         10.23372
NA
>>    NA        2.70852   NA      NA      12.85280    NA      NA
12.15737
>>    NA        NA        3.58508   NA       NA       -5.33030   NA
NA
>>  -2.80985  NA      NA      -0.57019  NA      NA      1.34960  NA
NA
>>  3.32039   NA      NA
>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P200     VGRD    P200
ANALYS
>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
>> CNT       104229 1.20188      1.13867      1.26508      NA       NA
>> 10.41115  10.36665   10.45604   NA         NA         0.00086
-0.06367
>>     0.06540      NA       NA       10.63064   10.58520   10.67648
NA
>>   NA         0.87388 0.87244     0.87531     NA          NA
NA
>>  NA      0     0          0          1.20102   1.16891   1.23312
NA     NA
>>     5.28821   5.26561    5.31101    NA         NA
1392.29592 NA
>>    NA        3.77652   NA      NA      29.40732    NA      NA
27.96488
>>    NA        NA        5.42285   NA       NA       -4.40088   NA
NA
>>  -1.85968  NA      NA      0.57003   NA      NA      3.58032  NA
NA
>>  7.38005   NA      NA
>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P850     VGRD    P850
ANALYS
>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
>> CNT       104229 -0.57983     -0.60585     -0.55380     NA       NA
>> 4.28728   4.26896    4.30577    NA         NA         -0.22396
-0.24579
>>     -0.20212     NA       NA       3.59671    3.58134    3.61222
NA
>>   NA         0.79578 0.79354     0.79800     NA          NA
NA
>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.35587  -0.37167  -0.34007
NA     NA
>>     2.60289   2.59176    2.61411    NA         NA         2.58899
NA
>>    NA        2.06063   NA      NA      6.90160     NA      NA
6.77495
>>   NA        NA        2.62709   NA       NA       -3.62999   NA
NA
>>  -2.03975  NA      NA      -0.30993  NA      NA      1.36034  NA
NA
>>  2.86965   NA      NA
>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 HGT      P500     HGT     P500
ANALYS
>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
>> CNT       104229 5757.47921   5756.67392   5758.28450   NA       NA
>> 132.64678 132.07980  133.21867  NA         NA         5760.36436
>> 5759.58847   5761.14026   NA       NA       127.80583  127.25955
128.35686
>>  NA         NA         0.99764 0.99761     0.99766     NA
NA
>>    NA      NA      0     0          0          -2.88515  -2.94694
-2.82337
>>  NA     NA     10.17761  10.13411   10.22149   NA         NA
0.99950
>>    NA        NA        7.19162   NA      NA      111.90687   NA
NA
>>  103.58276   NA        NA        10.57860  NA       NA
-13.39664  NA
>>    NA      -6.75918  NA      NA      -2.09283  NA      NA
2.76461  NA
>>    NA      7.51232   NA      NA
>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 RH       P700     RH      P700
ANALYS
>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
>> CNT       104229 50.53367     50.36545     50.70189     NA       NA
>> 27.70964  27.59120   27.82911   NA         NA         51.14431
50.97575
>>     51.31287     NA       NA       27.76553   27.64685   27.88524
NA
>>   NA         0.82485 0.82290     0.82678     NA          NA
NA
>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.61064  -0.71031  -0.51098
NA     NA
>>     16.41677  16.34660   16.48755   NA         NA         0.98806
NA
>>    NA        12.08873  NA      NA      269.88072   NA      NA
269.50784
>>   NA        NA        16.42805  NA       NA       -20.31021  NA
NA
>>  -9.32042  NA      NA      -0.75999  NA      NA      8.28050  NA
NA
>>  19.76888  NA      NA
>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 DPT      L002     DPT     L002
ANALYS
>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
>> CNT       104229 282.71981    282.62088    282.81874    NA       NA
>> 16.29619  16.22653   16.36645   NA         NA         281.86912
281.76724
>>    281.97100    NA       NA       16.78184   16.71011   16.85419
NA
>>   NA         0.98777 0.98762     0.98791     NA          NA
NA
>>  NA      0     0          0          0.85069   0.83471   0.86667
NA     NA
>>     2.63195   2.62070    2.64330    NA         NA         1.00302
NA
>>    NA        1.87497   NA      NA      7.65076     NA      NA
6.92709
>>   NA        NA        2.76600   NA       NA       -1.61755   NA
NA
>>  -0.14540  NA      NA      0.82517   NA      NA      1.76625  NA
NA
>>  3.58419   NA      NA
>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 TMP      L002     TMP     L002
ANALYS
>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
>> CNT       104229 288.08059    287.99342    288.16776    NA       NA
>> 14.35860  14.29722   14.42050   NA         NA         287.65343
287.55967
>>    287.74719    NA       NA       15.44427   15.37825   15.51085
NA
>>   NA         0.99355 0.99347     0.99362     NA          NA
NA
>>  NA      0     0          0          0.42716   0.41496   0.43937
NA     NA
>>     2.01018   2.00158    2.01884    NA         NA         1.00148
NA
>>    NA        1.37606   NA      NA      4.22324     NA      NA
4.04077
>>   NA        NA        2.05505   NA       NA       -1.33962   NA
NA
>>  -0.72940  NA      NA      -0.10933  NA      NA      1.16036  NA
NA
>>  3.27992   NA      NA
>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 PRMSL    L000     PRMSL   L000
ANALYS
>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
0.05000
>> CNT       104229 101506.27461 101500.32308 101512.22613 NA       NA
>> 980.33535 976.14508  984.56200  NA         NA         101552.32536
>> 101545.96644 101558.68428 NA       NA       1047.44127 1042.96417
1051.95724
>> NA         NA         0.97981 0.97956     0.98005     NA
NA
>>  NA      NA      0     0          0          -46.05075 -47.35240
-44.74911
>> NA     NA     214.40667 213.49022  215.33107  NA         NA
0.99955
>>    NA        NA        129.08656 NA      NA      48090.44934 NA
NA
>>  45969.77759 NA        NA        219.29535 NA       NA
-217.44225 NA
>>    NA      -98.55026 NA      NA      -24.52207 NA      NA
42.98074 NA
>>    NA      125.68678 NA      NA
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Dear Sir,
>>>
>>> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
>>> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
>> variable
>>> in the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
>>>
>>> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have uploaded
input
>>> files at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
>>> Please check my script, input file and output files.
>>>
>>>
>>> Thanks and Regards,
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Dear Sir,
>>>
>>> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
>>> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
>> variable in
>>> the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
>>>
>>> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have uploaded
input
>> files
>>> at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
>>> Please check my script, input file and output files.
>>>
>>>
>>> Thanks and Regards,
>>> --
>>> Hashmi Fatima
>>> Research Scholar
>>> Centre for Atmospheric Sciences
>>> Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
>>> Hauz Khas
>>> New Delhi - 110016
>>> INDIA
>>
>>
>>
>
>


------------------------------------------------
Subject: problem in grid_stat output
From: Hashmi Fatima
Time: Wed Feb 09 09:23:04 2011

Yes
I am comparing forecast with analysis grid to grid.

Assume

Observation: WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.000.grib1
model: WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.024.grib1



On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 9:33 PM, RAL HelpDesk {for Paul Oldenburg} <
met_help at ucar.edu> wrote:

> Hashmi,
>
> I assumed the files WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.000.grib1 and
WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.024.grib1
> were both model output files that you wanted
> to verify.  Is one of those file the observation data and one the
model
> data?
>
> Paul
>
> On 02/09/2011 08:52 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
> >
> > <URL: https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207 >
> >
> > No that was some old folder. I was trying to upload
wrf_t00z_000.grib1
> and
> > wrf_t00z.024.grib1 files. It was taking much time. so i left them
to
> > upload.
> >
> > I checked these files they were OK. I will try to send them
tomorrow.
> >
> > Regards,
> > Hashmi Fatima
> >
> > On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 9:15 PM, RAL HelpDesk {for Paul Oldenburg}
<
> > met_help at ucar.edu> wrote:
> >
> >> Hashmi,
> >>
> >> I was able to download your config file, test script, output
files and
> >> input GRIB files, but there are no observation
> >> files.  I see an empty folder on the FTP site called 2010070100.
Did
> you
> >> intend for that to contain observation data?
> >> If so, please upload it and I will look at your problem.
> >>
> >> Thanks,
> >>
> >> Paul
> >>
> >>
> >> On 02/09/2011 06:38 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
> >>>
> >>> Wed Feb 09 06:38:46 2011: Request 44207 was acted upon.
> >>> Transaction: Ticket created by hashmifatima at gmail.com
> >>>        Queue: met_help
> >>>      Subject: problem in grid_stat output
> >>>        Owner: Nobody
> >>>   Requestors: hashmifatima at gmail.com
> >>>       Status: new
> >>>  Ticket <URL:
https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207>
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> VERSION MODEL FCST_LEAD FCST_VALID_BEG  FCST_VALID_END  OBS_LEAD
> >> OBS_VALID_BEG   OBS_VALID_END   FCST_VAR FCST_LEV OBS_VAR OBS_LEV
OBTYPE
> >> VX_MASK INTERP_MTHD INTERP_PNTS FCST_THRESH OBS_THRESH COV_THRESH
ALPHA
> >> LINE_TYPE TOTAL  FBAR         FBAR_NCL     FBAR_NCU     FBAR_BCL
> FBAR_BCU
> >> FSTDEV    FSTDEV_NCL FSTDEV_NCU FSTDEV_BCL FSTDEV_BCU OBAR
> OBAR_NCL
> >>     OBAR_NCU     OBAR_BCL OBAR_BCU OSTDEV     OSTDEV_NCL
OSTDEV_NCU
> >> OSTDEV_BCL OSTDEV_BCU PR_CORR PR_CORR_NCL PR_CORR_NCU PR_CORR_BCL
> >> PR_CORR_BCU SP_CORR KT_CORR RANKS FRANK_TIES ORANK_TIES ME
ME_NCL
> >>  ME_NCU    ME_BCL ME_BCU ESTDEV    ESTDEV_NCL ESTDEV_NCU
ESTDEV_BCL
> >> ESTDEV_BCU MBIAS      MBIAS_BCL MBIAS_BCU MAE       MAE_BCL
MAE_BCU MSE
> >>     MSE_BCL MSE_BCU BCMSE       BCMSE_BCL BCMSE_BCU RMSE
RMSE_BCL
> >> RMSE_BCU E10        E10_BCL E10_BCU E25       E25_BCL E25_BCU E50
> >> E50_BCL E50_BCU E75      E75_BCL E75_BCU E90       E90_BCL
E90_BCU
> >>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P200     UGRD    P200
ANALYS
> >> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> 0.05000
> >> CNT       104229 12.72428     12.56397     12.88458     NA
NA
> >> 26.40506  26.29220   26.51890   NA         NA         13.31753
> 13.15803
> >>     13.47703     NA       NA       26.27261   26.16031   26.38588
NA
> >>   NA         0.97917 0.97892     0.97942     NA          NA
NA
> >>  NA      0     0          0          -0.59326  -0.62590  -0.56061
NA
>   NA
> >>     5.37733   5.35434    5.40051    NA         NA         0.95545
NA
> >>    NA        4.14550   NA      NA      29.26732    NA      NA
>  28.91537
> >>    NA        NA        5.40993   NA       NA       -7.53975   NA
NA
> >>  -3.73896  NA      NA      -0.01006  NA      NA      2.91055  NA
NA
> >>  5.69081   NA      NA
> >>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P850     UGRD    P850
ANALYS
> >> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> 0.05000
> >> CNT       104229 -0.92424     -0.96596     -0.88252     NA
NA
> >> 6.87219   6.84281    6.90182    NA         NA         -0.09031
> -0.12305
> >>     -0.05758     NA       NA       5.39198    5.36893    5.41523
NA
> >>   NA         0.86552 0.86399     0.86703     NA          NA
NA
> >>  NA      0     0          0          -0.83392  -0.85509  -0.81276
NA
>   NA
> >>     3.48676   3.47186    3.50179    NA         NA
10.23372   NA
> >>    NA        2.70852   NA      NA      12.85280    NA      NA
>  12.15737
> >>    NA        NA        3.58508   NA       NA       -5.33030   NA
NA
> >>  -2.80985  NA      NA      -0.57019  NA      NA      1.34960  NA
NA
> >>  3.32039   NA      NA
> >>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P200     VGRD    P200
ANALYS
> >> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> 0.05000
> >> CNT       104229 1.20188      1.13867      1.26508      NA
NA
> >> 10.41115  10.36665   10.45604   NA         NA         0.00086
>  -0.06367
> >>     0.06540      NA       NA       10.63064   10.58520   10.67648
NA
> >>   NA         0.87388 0.87244     0.87531     NA          NA
NA
> >>  NA      0     0          0          1.20102   1.16891   1.23312
NA
>   NA
> >>     5.28821   5.26561    5.31101    NA         NA
1392.29592 NA
> >>    NA        3.77652   NA      NA      29.40732    NA      NA
>  27.96488
> >>    NA        NA        5.42285   NA       NA       -4.40088   NA
NA
> >>  -1.85968  NA      NA      0.57003   NA      NA      3.58032  NA
NA
> >>  7.38005   NA      NA
> >>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P850     VGRD    P850
ANALYS
> >> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> 0.05000
> >> CNT       104229 -0.57983     -0.60585     -0.55380     NA
NA
> >> 4.28728   4.26896    4.30577    NA         NA         -0.22396
> -0.24579
> >>     -0.20212     NA       NA       3.59671    3.58134    3.61222
NA
> >>   NA         0.79578 0.79354     0.79800     NA          NA
NA
> >>  NA      0     0          0          -0.35587  -0.37167  -0.34007
NA
>   NA
> >>     2.60289   2.59176    2.61411    NA         NA         2.58899
NA
> >>    NA        2.06063   NA      NA      6.90160     NA      NA
>  6.77495
> >>   NA        NA        2.62709   NA       NA       -3.62999   NA
NA
> >>  -2.03975  NA      NA      -0.30993  NA      NA      1.36034  NA
NA
> >>  2.86965   NA      NA
> >>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 HGT      P500     HGT     P500
ANALYS
> >> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> 0.05000
> >> CNT       104229 5757.47921   5756.67392   5758.28450   NA
NA
> >> 132.64678 132.07980  133.21867  NA         NA         5760.36436
> >> 5759.58847   5761.14026   NA       NA       127.80583  127.25955
>  128.35686
> >>  NA         NA         0.99764 0.99761     0.99766     NA
NA
> >>    NA      NA      0     0          0          -2.88515  -2.94694
>  -2.82337
> >>  NA     NA     10.17761  10.13411   10.22149   NA         NA
> 0.99950
> >>    NA        NA        7.19162   NA      NA      111.90687   NA
NA
> >>  103.58276   NA        NA        10.57860  NA       NA
-13.39664
>  NA
> >>    NA      -6.75918  NA      NA      -2.09283  NA      NA
2.76461
>  NA
> >>    NA      7.51232   NA      NA
> >>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 RH       P700     RH      P700
ANALYS
> >> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> 0.05000
> >> CNT       104229 50.53367     50.36545     50.70189     NA
NA
> >> 27.70964  27.59120   27.82911   NA         NA         51.14431
> 50.97575
> >>     51.31287     NA       NA       27.76553   27.64685   27.88524
NA
> >>   NA         0.82485 0.82290     0.82678     NA          NA
NA
> >>  NA      0     0          0          -0.61064  -0.71031  -0.51098
NA
>   NA
> >>     16.41677  16.34660   16.48755   NA         NA         0.98806
NA
> >>    NA        12.08873  NA      NA      269.88072   NA      NA
>  269.50784
> >>   NA        NA        16.42805  NA       NA       -20.31021  NA
NA
> >>  -9.32042  NA      NA      -0.75999  NA      NA      8.28050  NA
NA
> >>  19.76888  NA      NA
> >>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 DPT      L002     DPT     L002
ANALYS
> >> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> 0.05000
> >> CNT       104229 282.71981    282.62088    282.81874    NA
NA
> >> 16.29619  16.22653   16.36645   NA         NA         281.86912
>  281.76724
> >>    281.97100    NA       NA       16.78184   16.71011   16.85419
NA
> >>   NA         0.98777 0.98762     0.98791     NA          NA
NA
> >>  NA      0     0          0          0.85069   0.83471   0.86667
NA
>   NA
> >>     2.63195   2.62070    2.64330    NA         NA         1.00302
NA
> >>    NA        1.87497   NA      NA      7.65076     NA      NA
>  6.92709
> >>   NA        NA        2.76600   NA       NA       -1.61755   NA
NA
> >>  -0.14540  NA      NA      0.82517   NA      NA      1.76625  NA
NA
> >>  3.58419   NA      NA
> >>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 TMP      L002     TMP     L002
ANALYS
> >> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> 0.05000
> >> CNT       104229 288.08059    287.99342    288.16776    NA
NA
> >> 14.35860  14.29722   14.42050   NA         NA         287.65343
>  287.55967
> >>    287.74719    NA       NA       15.44427   15.37825   15.51085
NA
> >>   NA         0.99355 0.99347     0.99362     NA          NA
NA
> >>  NA      0     0          0          0.42716   0.41496   0.43937
NA
>   NA
> >>     2.01018   2.00158    2.01884    NA         NA         1.00148
NA
> >>    NA        1.37606   NA      NA      4.22324     NA      NA
>  4.04077
> >>   NA        NA        2.05505   NA       NA       -1.33962   NA
NA
> >>  -0.72940  NA      NA      -0.10933  NA      NA      1.16036  NA
NA
> >>  3.27992   NA      NA
> >>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 PRMSL    L000     PRMSL   L000
ANALYS
> >> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> 0.05000
> >> CNT       104229 101506.27461 101500.32308 101512.22613 NA
NA
> >> 980.33535 976.14508  984.56200  NA         NA
101552.32536
> >> 101545.96644 101558.68428 NA       NA       1047.44127 1042.96417
> 1051.95724
> >> NA         NA         0.97981 0.97956     0.98005     NA
NA
> >>  NA      NA      0     0          0          -46.05075 -47.35240
> -44.74911
> >> NA     NA     214.40667 213.49022  215.33107  NA         NA
> 0.99955
> >>    NA        NA        129.08656 NA      NA      48090.44934 NA
NA
> >>  45969.77759 NA        NA        219.29535 NA       NA
-217.44225
> NA
> >>    NA      -98.55026 NA      NA      -24.52207 NA      NA
42.98074
> NA
> >>    NA      125.68678 NA      NA
> >>>
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> Dear Sir,
> >>>
> >>> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
> >>> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
> >> variable
> >>> in the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
> >>>
> >>> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have
uploaded
> input
> >>> files at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
> >>> Please check my script, input file and output files.
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> Thanks and Regards,
> >>>
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> Dear Sir,
> >>>
> >>> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
> >>> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
> >> variable in
> >>> the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
> >>>
> >>> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have
uploaded
> input
> >> files
> >>> at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
> >>> Please check my script, input file and output files.
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> Thanks and Regards,
> >>> --
> >>> Hashmi Fatima
> >>> Research Scholar
> >>> Centre for Atmospheric Sciences
> >>> Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
> >>> Hauz Khas
> >>> New Delhi - 110016
> >>> INDIA
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >
> >
>
>
>


--
Hashmi Fatima
Research Scholar
Centre for Atmospheric Sciences
Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
Hauz Khas
New Delhi - 110016
INDIA

------------------------------------------------
Subject: Re: [rt.rap.ucar.edu #44207] problem in grid_stat output
From: Paul Oldenburg
Time: Wed Feb 09 11:18:43 2011

Hashmi,

If you examine the output file
grid_stat_UVTH_240000L_20110104_000000V_cnt.txt, you see that the fbar
(average forecast)
value for the VGRD at P200 is 1.20188 and the obar value is 0.00086.
Page C-8 in the MET User's Guide, which I suggest
you read, shows that MBIAS is defined as the ratio of fbar to obar.
In this case MBIAS = 1.20188 / 0.00086 = 1397.53.
The high value is due to the nature of ratios: big numbers divided by
small numbers produce bigger numbers.  It is
important that you understand the meaning behind the statistics that
you calculate when you use MET.  For your
application, a statistic such as mean error or mean absolute error may
be more appropriate than multiplicative bias.
You must decide based on the type of analysis you are doing.

Tressa, do you have any other input for Hashmi?

Thanks,

Paul

On 02/09/2011 09:23 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
>
> <URL: https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207 >
>
> Yes
> I am comparing forecast with analysis grid to grid.
>
> Assume
>
> Observation: WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.000.grib1
> model: WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.024.grib1
>
>
>
> On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 9:33 PM, RAL HelpDesk {for Paul Oldenburg} <
> met_help at ucar.edu> wrote:
>
>> Hashmi,
>>
>> I assumed the files WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.000.grib1 and
WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.024.grib1
>> were both model output files that you wanted
>> to verify.  Is one of those file the observation data and one the
model
>> data?
>>
>> Paul
>>
>> On 02/09/2011 08:52 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
>>>
>>> <URL: https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207 >
>>>
>>> No that was some old folder. I was trying to upload
wrf_t00z_000.grib1
>> and
>>> wrf_t00z.024.grib1 files. It was taking much time. so i left them
to
>>> upload.
>>>
>>> I checked these files they were OK. I will try to send them
tomorrow.
>>>
>>> Regards,
>>> Hashmi Fatima
>>>
>>> On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 9:15 PM, RAL HelpDesk {for Paul Oldenburg}
<
>>> met_help at ucar.edu> wrote:
>>>
>>>> Hashmi,
>>>>
>>>> I was able to download your config file, test script, output
files and
>>>> input GRIB files, but there are no observation
>>>> files.  I see an empty folder on the FTP site called 2010070100.
Did
>> you
>>>> intend for that to contain observation data?
>>>> If so, please upload it and I will look at your problem.
>>>>
>>>> Thanks,
>>>>
>>>> Paul
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> On 02/09/2011 06:38 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> Wed Feb 09 06:38:46 2011: Request 44207 was acted upon.
>>>>> Transaction: Ticket created by hashmifatima at gmail.com
>>>>>        Queue: met_help
>>>>>      Subject: problem in grid_stat output
>>>>>        Owner: Nobody
>>>>>   Requestors: hashmifatima at gmail.com
>>>>>       Status: new
>>>>>  Ticket <URL:
https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> VERSION MODEL FCST_LEAD FCST_VALID_BEG  FCST_VALID_END  OBS_LEAD
>>>> OBS_VALID_BEG   OBS_VALID_END   FCST_VAR FCST_LEV OBS_VAR OBS_LEV
OBTYPE
>>>> VX_MASK INTERP_MTHD INTERP_PNTS FCST_THRESH OBS_THRESH COV_THRESH
ALPHA
>>>> LINE_TYPE TOTAL  FBAR         FBAR_NCL     FBAR_NCU     FBAR_BCL
>> FBAR_BCU
>>>> FSTDEV    FSTDEV_NCL FSTDEV_NCU FSTDEV_BCL FSTDEV_BCU OBAR
>> OBAR_NCL
>>>>     OBAR_NCU     OBAR_BCL OBAR_BCU OSTDEV     OSTDEV_NCL
OSTDEV_NCU
>>>> OSTDEV_BCL OSTDEV_BCU PR_CORR PR_CORR_NCL PR_CORR_NCU PR_CORR_BCL
>>>> PR_CORR_BCU SP_CORR KT_CORR RANKS FRANK_TIES ORANK_TIES ME
ME_NCL
>>>>  ME_NCU    ME_BCL ME_BCU ESTDEV    ESTDEV_NCL ESTDEV_NCU
ESTDEV_BCL
>>>> ESTDEV_BCU MBIAS      MBIAS_BCL MBIAS_BCU MAE       MAE_BCL
MAE_BCU MSE
>>>>     MSE_BCL MSE_BCU BCMSE       BCMSE_BCL BCMSE_BCU RMSE
RMSE_BCL
>>>> RMSE_BCU E10        E10_BCL E10_BCU E25       E25_BCL E25_BCU E50
>>>> E50_BCL E50_BCU E75      E75_BCL E75_BCU E90       E90_BCL
E90_BCU
>>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P200     UGRD    P200
ANALYS
>>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
>> 0.05000
>>>> CNT       104229 12.72428     12.56397     12.88458     NA
NA
>>>> 26.40506  26.29220   26.51890   NA         NA         13.31753
>> 13.15803
>>>>     13.47703     NA       NA       26.27261   26.16031   26.38588
NA
>>>>   NA         0.97917 0.97892     0.97942     NA          NA
NA
>>>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.59326  -0.62590  -0.56061
NA
>>   NA
>>>>     5.37733   5.35434    5.40051    NA         NA         0.95545
NA
>>>>    NA        4.14550   NA      NA      29.26732    NA      NA
>>  28.91537
>>>>    NA        NA        5.40993   NA       NA       -7.53975   NA
NA
>>>>  -3.73896  NA      NA      -0.01006  NA      NA      2.91055  NA
NA
>>>>  5.69081   NA      NA
>>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P850     UGRD    P850
ANALYS
>>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
>> 0.05000
>>>> CNT       104229 -0.92424     -0.96596     -0.88252     NA
NA
>>>> 6.87219   6.84281    6.90182    NA         NA         -0.09031
>> -0.12305
>>>>     -0.05758     NA       NA       5.39198    5.36893    5.41523
NA
>>>>   NA         0.86552 0.86399     0.86703     NA          NA
NA
>>>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.83392  -0.85509  -0.81276
NA
>>   NA
>>>>     3.48676   3.47186    3.50179    NA         NA
10.23372   NA
>>>>    NA        2.70852   NA      NA      12.85280    NA      NA
>>  12.15737
>>>>    NA        NA        3.58508   NA       NA       -5.33030   NA
NA
>>>>  -2.80985  NA      NA      -0.57019  NA      NA      1.34960  NA
NA
>>>>  3.32039   NA      NA
>>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P200     VGRD    P200
ANALYS
>>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
>> 0.05000
>>>> CNT       104229 1.20188      1.13867      1.26508      NA
NA
>>>> 10.41115  10.36665   10.45604   NA         NA         0.00086
>>  -0.06367
>>>>     0.06540      NA       NA       10.63064   10.58520   10.67648
NA
>>>>   NA         0.87388 0.87244     0.87531     NA          NA
NA
>>>>  NA      0     0          0          1.20102   1.16891   1.23312
NA
>>   NA
>>>>     5.28821   5.26561    5.31101    NA         NA
1392.29592 NA
>>>>    NA        3.77652   NA      NA      29.40732    NA      NA
>>  27.96488
>>>>    NA        NA        5.42285   NA       NA       -4.40088   NA
NA
>>>>  -1.85968  NA      NA      0.57003   NA      NA      3.58032  NA
NA
>>>>  7.38005   NA      NA
>>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P850     VGRD    P850
ANALYS
>>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
>> 0.05000
>>>> CNT       104229 -0.57983     -0.60585     -0.55380     NA
NA
>>>> 4.28728   4.26896    4.30577    NA         NA         -0.22396
>> -0.24579
>>>>     -0.20212     NA       NA       3.59671    3.58134    3.61222
NA
>>>>   NA         0.79578 0.79354     0.79800     NA          NA
NA
>>>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.35587  -0.37167  -0.34007
NA
>>   NA
>>>>     2.60289   2.59176    2.61411    NA         NA         2.58899
NA
>>>>    NA        2.06063   NA      NA      6.90160     NA      NA
>>  6.77495
>>>>   NA        NA        2.62709   NA       NA       -3.62999   NA
NA
>>>>  -2.03975  NA      NA      -0.30993  NA      NA      1.36034  NA
NA
>>>>  2.86965   NA      NA
>>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 HGT      P500     HGT     P500
ANALYS
>>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
>> 0.05000
>>>> CNT       104229 5757.47921   5756.67392   5758.28450   NA
NA
>>>> 132.64678 132.07980  133.21867  NA         NA         5760.36436
>>>> 5759.58847   5761.14026   NA       NA       127.80583  127.25955
>>  128.35686
>>>>  NA         NA         0.99764 0.99761     0.99766     NA
NA
>>>>    NA      NA      0     0          0          -2.88515  -2.94694
>>  -2.82337
>>>>  NA     NA     10.17761  10.13411   10.22149   NA         NA
>> 0.99950
>>>>    NA        NA        7.19162   NA      NA      111.90687   NA
NA
>>>>  103.58276   NA        NA        10.57860  NA       NA
-13.39664
>>  NA
>>>>    NA      -6.75918  NA      NA      -2.09283  NA      NA
2.76461
>>  NA
>>>>    NA      7.51232   NA      NA
>>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 RH       P700     RH      P700
ANALYS
>>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
>> 0.05000
>>>> CNT       104229 50.53367     50.36545     50.70189     NA
NA
>>>> 27.70964  27.59120   27.82911   NA         NA         51.14431
>> 50.97575
>>>>     51.31287     NA       NA       27.76553   27.64685   27.88524
NA
>>>>   NA         0.82485 0.82290     0.82678     NA          NA
NA
>>>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.61064  -0.71031  -0.51098
NA
>>   NA
>>>>     16.41677  16.34660   16.48755   NA         NA         0.98806
NA
>>>>    NA        12.08873  NA      NA      269.88072   NA      NA
>>  269.50784
>>>>   NA        NA        16.42805  NA       NA       -20.31021  NA
NA
>>>>  -9.32042  NA      NA      -0.75999  NA      NA      8.28050  NA
NA
>>>>  19.76888  NA      NA
>>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 DPT      L002     DPT     L002
ANALYS
>>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
>> 0.05000
>>>> CNT       104229 282.71981    282.62088    282.81874    NA
NA
>>>> 16.29619  16.22653   16.36645   NA         NA         281.86912
>>  281.76724
>>>>    281.97100    NA       NA       16.78184   16.71011   16.85419
NA
>>>>   NA         0.98777 0.98762     0.98791     NA          NA
NA
>>>>  NA      0     0          0          0.85069   0.83471   0.86667
NA
>>   NA
>>>>     2.63195   2.62070    2.64330    NA         NA         1.00302
NA
>>>>    NA        1.87497   NA      NA      7.65076     NA      NA
>>  6.92709
>>>>   NA        NA        2.76600   NA       NA       -1.61755   NA
NA
>>>>  -0.14540  NA      NA      0.82517   NA      NA      1.76625  NA
NA
>>>>  3.58419   NA      NA
>>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 TMP      L002     TMP     L002
ANALYS
>>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
>> 0.05000
>>>> CNT       104229 288.08059    287.99342    288.16776    NA
NA
>>>> 14.35860  14.29722   14.42050   NA         NA         287.65343
>>  287.55967
>>>>    287.74719    NA       NA       15.44427   15.37825   15.51085
NA
>>>>   NA         0.99355 0.99347     0.99362     NA          NA
NA
>>>>  NA      0     0          0          0.42716   0.41496   0.43937
NA
>>   NA
>>>>     2.01018   2.00158    2.01884    NA         NA         1.00148
NA
>>>>    NA        1.37606   NA      NA      4.22324     NA      NA
>>  4.04077
>>>>   NA        NA        2.05505   NA       NA       -1.33962   NA
NA
>>>>  -0.72940  NA      NA      -0.10933  NA      NA      1.16036  NA
NA
>>>>  3.27992   NA      NA
>>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
>>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 PRMSL    L000     PRMSL   L000
ANALYS
>>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
>> 0.05000
>>>> CNT       104229 101506.27461 101500.32308 101512.22613 NA
NA
>>>> 980.33535 976.14508  984.56200  NA         NA
101552.32536
>>>> 101545.96644 101558.68428 NA       NA       1047.44127 1042.96417
>> 1051.95724
>>>> NA         NA         0.97981 0.97956     0.98005     NA
NA
>>>>  NA      NA      0     0          0          -46.05075 -47.35240
>> -44.74911
>>>> NA     NA     214.40667 213.49022  215.33107  NA         NA
>> 0.99955
>>>>    NA        NA        129.08656 NA      NA      48090.44934 NA
NA
>>>>  45969.77759 NA        NA        219.29535 NA       NA
-217.44225
>> NA
>>>>    NA      -98.55026 NA      NA      -24.52207 NA      NA
42.98074
>> NA
>>>>    NA      125.68678 NA      NA
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Dear Sir,
>>>>>
>>>>> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
>>>>> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
>>>> variable
>>>>> in the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
>>>>>
>>>>> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have
uploaded
>> input
>>>>> files at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
>>>>> Please check my script, input file and output files.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Thanks and Regards,
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Dear Sir,
>>>>>
>>>>> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
>>>>> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
>>>> variable in
>>>>> the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
>>>>>
>>>>> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have
uploaded
>> input
>>>> files
>>>>> at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
>>>>> Please check my script, input file and output files.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Thanks and Regards,
>>>>> --
>>>>> Hashmi Fatima
>>>>> Research Scholar
>>>>> Centre for Atmospheric Sciences
>>>>> Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
>>>>> Hauz Khas
>>>>> New Delhi - 110016
>>>>> INDIA
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>>>
>>
>>
>>
>
>


------------------------------------------------
Subject: problem in grid_stat output
From: Hashmi Fatima
Time: Wed Feb 09 11:37:26 2011

Thank you so much for this reply.

 I guessed so when I got this value of MBIAS that the value in the
denominator may be too small thats why I am getting such a high value
of
MBIAS.

Best Regards
Hashmi Fatima




On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 11:48 PM, RAL HelpDesk {for Paul Oldenburg} <
met_help at ucar.edu> wrote:

> Hashmi,
>
> If you examine the output file
> grid_stat_UVTH_240000L_20110104_000000V_cnt.txt, you see that the
fbar
> (average forecast)
> value for the VGRD at P200 is 1.20188 and the obar value is 0.00086.
Page
> C-8 in the MET User's Guide, which I suggest
> you read, shows that MBIAS is defined as the ratio of fbar to obar.
In
> this case MBIAS = 1.20188 / 0.00086 = 1397.53.
> The high value is due to the nature of ratios: big numbers divided
by small
> numbers produce bigger numbers.  It is
> important that you understand the meaning behind the statistics that
you
> calculate when you use MET.  For your
> application, a statistic such as mean error or mean absolute error
may be
> more appropriate than multiplicative bias.
> You must decide based on the type of analysis you are doing.
>
> Tressa, do you have any other input for Hashmi?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Paul
>
> On 02/09/2011 09:23 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
> >
> > <URL: https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207 >
> >
> > Yes
> > I am comparing forecast with analysis grid to grid.
> >
> > Assume
> >
> > Observation: WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.000.grib1
> > model: WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.024.grib1
> >
> >
> >
> > On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 9:33 PM, RAL HelpDesk {for Paul Oldenburg}
<
> > met_help at ucar.edu> wrote:
> >
> >> Hashmi,
> >>
> >> I assumed the files WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.000.grib1 and
> WRF_HQ.t00z_d01.024.grib1
> >> were both model output files that you wanted
> >> to verify.  Is one of those file the observation data and one the
model
> >> data?
> >>
> >> Paul
> >>
> >> On 02/09/2011 08:52 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
> >>>
> >>> <URL: https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207 >
> >>>
> >>> No that was some old folder. I was trying to upload
wrf_t00z_000.grib1
> >> and
> >>> wrf_t00z.024.grib1 files. It was taking much time. so i left
them to
> >>> upload.
> >>>
> >>> I checked these files they were OK. I will try to send them
tomorrow.
> >>>
> >>> Regards,
> >>> Hashmi Fatima
> >>>
> >>> On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 9:15 PM, RAL HelpDesk {for Paul
Oldenburg} <
> >>> met_help at ucar.edu> wrote:
> >>>
> >>>> Hashmi,
> >>>>
> >>>> I was able to download your config file, test script, output
files and
> >>>> input GRIB files, but there are no observation
> >>>> files.  I see an empty folder on the FTP site called
2010070100.  Did
> >> you
> >>>> intend for that to contain observation data?
> >>>> If so, please upload it and I will look at your problem.
> >>>>
> >>>> Thanks,
> >>>>
> >>>> Paul
> >>>>
> >>>>
> >>>> On 02/09/2011 06:38 AM, RAL HelpDesk {for Hashmi Fatima} wrote:
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Wed Feb 09 06:38:46 2011: Request 44207 was acted upon.
> >>>>> Transaction: Ticket created by hashmifatima at gmail.com
> >>>>>        Queue: met_help
> >>>>>      Subject: problem in grid_stat output
> >>>>>        Owner: Nobody
> >>>>>   Requestors: hashmifatima at gmail.com
> >>>>>       Status: new
> >>>>>  Ticket <URL:
> https://rt.rap.ucar.edu/rt/Ticket/Display.html?id=44207>
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>> VERSION MODEL FCST_LEAD FCST_VALID_BEG  FCST_VALID_END
OBS_LEAD
> >>>> OBS_VALID_BEG   OBS_VALID_END   FCST_VAR FCST_LEV OBS_VAR
OBS_LEV
> OBTYPE
> >>>> VX_MASK INTERP_MTHD INTERP_PNTS FCST_THRESH OBS_THRESH
COV_THRESH
> ALPHA
> >>>> LINE_TYPE TOTAL  FBAR         FBAR_NCL     FBAR_NCU
FBAR_BCL
> >> FBAR_BCU
> >>>> FSTDEV    FSTDEV_NCL FSTDEV_NCU FSTDEV_BCL FSTDEV_BCU OBAR
> >> OBAR_NCL
> >>>>     OBAR_NCU     OBAR_BCL OBAR_BCU OSTDEV     OSTDEV_NCL
OSTDEV_NCU
> >>>> OSTDEV_BCL OSTDEV_BCU PR_CORR PR_CORR_NCL PR_CORR_NCU
PR_CORR_BCL
> >>>> PR_CORR_BCU SP_CORR KT_CORR RANKS FRANK_TIES ORANK_TIES ME
>  ME_NCL
> >>>>  ME_NCU    ME_BCL ME_BCU ESTDEV    ESTDEV_NCL ESTDEV_NCU
ESTDEV_BCL
> >>>> ESTDEV_BCU MBIAS      MBIAS_BCL MBIAS_BCU MAE       MAE_BCL
MAE_BCU
> MSE
> >>>>     MSE_BCL MSE_BCU BCMSE       BCMSE_BCL BCMSE_BCU RMSE
RMSE_BCL
> >>>> RMSE_BCU E10        E10_BCL E10_BCU E25       E25_BCL E25_BCU
E50
> >>>> E50_BCL E50_BCU E75      E75_BCL E75_BCU E90       E90_BCL
E90_BCU
> >>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P200     UGRD    P200
>  ANALYS
> >>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> >> 0.05000
> >>>> CNT       104229 12.72428     12.56397     12.88458     NA
NA
> >>>> 26.40506  26.29220   26.51890   NA         NA         13.31753
> >> 13.15803
> >>>>     13.47703     NA       NA       26.27261   26.16031
26.38588   NA
> >>>>   NA         0.97917 0.97892     0.97942     NA          NA
>  NA
> >>>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.59326  -0.62590
-0.56061  NA
> >>   NA
> >>>>     5.37733   5.35434    5.40051    NA         NA
0.95545
>  NA
> >>>>    NA        4.14550   NA      NA      29.26732    NA      NA
> >>  28.91537
> >>>>    NA        NA        5.40993   NA       NA       -7.53975
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  -3.73896  NA      NA      -0.01006  NA      NA      2.91055
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  5.69081   NA      NA
> >>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 UGRD     P850     UGRD    P850
>  ANALYS
> >>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> >> 0.05000
> >>>> CNT       104229 -0.92424     -0.96596     -0.88252     NA
NA
> >>>> 6.87219   6.84281    6.90182    NA         NA         -0.09031
> >> -0.12305
> >>>>     -0.05758     NA       NA       5.39198    5.36893
5.41523    NA
> >>>>   NA         0.86552 0.86399     0.86703     NA          NA
>  NA
> >>>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.83392  -0.85509
-0.81276  NA
> >>   NA
> >>>>     3.48676   3.47186    3.50179    NA         NA
10.23372
> NA
> >>>>    NA        2.70852   NA      NA      12.85280    NA      NA
> >>  12.15737
> >>>>    NA        NA        3.58508   NA       NA       -5.33030
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  -2.80985  NA      NA      -0.57019  NA      NA      1.34960
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  3.32039   NA      NA
> >>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P200     VGRD    P200
>  ANALYS
> >>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> >> 0.05000
> >>>> CNT       104229 1.20188      1.13867      1.26508      NA
NA
> >>>> 10.41115  10.36665   10.45604   NA         NA         0.00086
> >>  -0.06367
> >>>>     0.06540      NA       NA       10.63064   10.58520
10.67648   NA
> >>>>   NA         0.87388 0.87244     0.87531     NA          NA
>  NA
> >>>>  NA      0     0          0          1.20102   1.16891
1.23312   NA
> >>   NA
> >>>>     5.28821   5.26561    5.31101    NA         NA
1392.29592
> NA
> >>>>    NA        3.77652   NA      NA      29.40732    NA      NA
> >>  27.96488
> >>>>    NA        NA        5.42285   NA       NA       -4.40088
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  -1.85968  NA      NA      0.57003   NA      NA      3.58032
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  7.38005   NA      NA
> >>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 VGRD     P850     VGRD    P850
>  ANALYS
> >>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> >> 0.05000
> >>>> CNT       104229 -0.57983     -0.60585     -0.55380     NA
NA
> >>>> 4.28728   4.26896    4.30577    NA         NA         -0.22396
> >> -0.24579
> >>>>     -0.20212     NA       NA       3.59671    3.58134
3.61222    NA
> >>>>   NA         0.79578 0.79354     0.79800     NA          NA
>  NA
> >>>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.35587  -0.37167
-0.34007  NA
> >>   NA
> >>>>     2.60289   2.59176    2.61411    NA         NA
2.58899
>  NA
> >>>>    NA        2.06063   NA      NA      6.90160     NA      NA
> >>  6.77495
> >>>>   NA        NA        2.62709   NA       NA       -3.62999   NA
>  NA
> >>>>  -2.03975  NA      NA      -0.30993  NA      NA      1.36034
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  2.86965   NA      NA
> >>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 HGT      P500     HGT     P500
>  ANALYS
> >>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> >> 0.05000
> >>>> CNT       104229 5757.47921   5756.67392   5758.28450   NA
NA
> >>>> 132.64678 132.07980  133.21867  NA         NA
5760.36436
> >>>> 5759.58847   5761.14026   NA       NA       127.80583
127.25955
> >>  128.35686
> >>>>  NA         NA         0.99764 0.99761     0.99766     NA
NA
> >>>>    NA      NA      0     0          0          -2.88515
-2.94694
> >>  -2.82337
> >>>>  NA     NA     10.17761  10.13411   10.22149   NA         NA
> >> 0.99950
> >>>>    NA        NA        7.19162   NA      NA      111.90687   NA
>  NA
> >>>>  103.58276   NA        NA        10.57860  NA       NA
-13.39664
> >>  NA
> >>>>    NA      -6.75918  NA      NA      -2.09283  NA      NA
2.76461
> >>  NA
> >>>>    NA      7.51232   NA      NA
> >>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 RH       P700     RH      P700
>  ANALYS
> >>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> >> 0.05000
> >>>> CNT       104229 50.53367     50.36545     50.70189     NA
NA
> >>>> 27.70964  27.59120   27.82911   NA         NA         51.14431
> >> 50.97575
> >>>>     51.31287     NA       NA       27.76553   27.64685
27.88524   NA
> >>>>   NA         0.82485 0.82290     0.82678     NA          NA
>  NA
> >>>>  NA      0     0          0          -0.61064  -0.71031
-0.51098  NA
> >>   NA
> >>>>     16.41677  16.34660   16.48755   NA         NA
0.98806
>  NA
> >>>>    NA        12.08873  NA      NA      269.88072   NA      NA
> >>  269.50784
> >>>>   NA        NA        16.42805  NA       NA       -20.31021  NA
>  NA
> >>>>  -9.32042  NA      NA      -0.75999  NA      NA      8.28050
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  19.76888  NA      NA
> >>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 DPT      L002     DPT     L002
>  ANALYS
> >>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> >> 0.05000
> >>>> CNT       104229 282.71981    282.62088    282.81874    NA
NA
> >>>> 16.29619  16.22653   16.36645   NA         NA         281.86912
> >>  281.76724
> >>>>    281.97100    NA       NA       16.78184   16.71011
16.85419   NA
> >>>>   NA         0.98777 0.98762     0.98791     NA          NA
>  NA
> >>>>  NA      0     0          0          0.85069   0.83471
0.86667   NA
> >>   NA
> >>>>     2.63195   2.62070    2.64330    NA         NA
1.00302
>  NA
> >>>>    NA        1.87497   NA      NA      7.65076     NA      NA
> >>  6.92709
> >>>>   NA        NA        2.76600   NA       NA       -1.61755   NA
>  NA
> >>>>  -0.14540  NA      NA      0.82517   NA      NA      1.76625
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  3.58419   NA      NA
> >>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 TMP      L002     TMP     L002
>  ANALYS
> >>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> >> 0.05000
> >>>> CNT       104229 288.08059    287.99342    288.16776    NA
NA
> >>>> 14.35860  14.29722   14.42050   NA         NA         287.65343
> >>  287.55967
> >>>>    287.74719    NA       NA       15.44427   15.37825
15.51085   NA
> >>>>   NA         0.99355 0.99347     0.99362     NA          NA
>  NA
> >>>>  NA      0     0          0          0.42716   0.41496
0.43937   NA
> >>   NA
> >>>>     2.01018   2.00158    2.01884    NA         NA
1.00148
>  NA
> >>>>    NA        1.37606   NA      NA      4.22324     NA      NA
> >>  4.04077
> >>>>   NA        NA        2.05505   NA       NA       -1.33962   NA
>  NA
> >>>>  -0.72940  NA      NA      -0.10933  NA      NA      1.16036
NA
>  NA
> >>>>  3.27992   NA      NA
> >>>>> V3.0    WRF   240000    20110104_000000 20110104_000000 000000
> >>>> 20110104_000000 20110104_000000 PRMSL    L000     PRMSL   L000
>  ANALYS
> >>>> FULL    UW_MEAN     1           NA          NA         NA
> >> 0.05000
> >>>> CNT       104229 101506.27461 101500.32308 101512.22613 NA
NA
> >>>> 980.33535 976.14508  984.56200  NA         NA
101552.32536
> >>>> 101545.96644 101558.68428 NA       NA       1047.44127
1042.96417
> >> 1051.95724
> >>>> NA         NA         0.97981 0.97956     0.98005     NA
NA
> >>>>  NA      NA      0     0          0          -46.05075
-47.35240
> >> -44.74911
> >>>> NA     NA     214.40667 213.49022  215.33107  NA         NA
> >> 0.99955
> >>>>    NA        NA        129.08656 NA      NA      48090.44934 NA
>  NA
> >>>>  45969.77759 NA        NA        219.29535 NA       NA
> -217.44225
> >> NA
> >>>>    NA      -98.55026 NA      NA      -24.52207 NA      NA
>  42.98074
> >> NA
> >>>>    NA      125.68678 NA      NA
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Dear Sir,
> >>>>>
> >>>>> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
> >>>>> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
> >>>> variable
> >>>>> in the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
> >>>>>
> >>>>> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have
uploaded
> >> input
> >>>>> files at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
> >>>>> Please check my script, input file and output files.
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Thanks and Regards,
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Dear Sir,
> >>>>>
> >>>>> I am running grid-stat tool and computing MBIAS, RMSE etc.
> >>>>> The MBIAS value for VGRD at P200 is coming very high. For all
other
> >>>> variable in
> >>>>> the same file it is coming normal. why it is so??
> >>>>>
> >>>>> I am sending you input files, script, config file. I have
uploaded
> >> input
> >>>> files
> >>>>> at your ftp address in my folder fatima_data.
> >>>>> Please check my script, input file and output files.
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Thanks and Regards,
> >>>>> --
> >>>>> Hashmi Fatima
> >>>>> Research Scholar
> >>>>> Centre for Atmospheric Sciences
> >>>>> Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
> >>>>> Hauz Khas
> >>>>> New Delhi - 110016
> >>>>> INDIA
> >>>>
> >>>>
> >>>>
> >>>
> >>>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >
> >
>
>
>


--
Hashmi Fatima
Research Scholar
Centre for Atmospheric Sciences
Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
Hauz Khas
New Delhi - 110016
INDIA

------------------------------------------------


More information about the Met_help mailing list